Choosing a freelance PR consultant: references decide

This article was created with the help of AI.
Two people in an introductory meeting: communications managers review the documents of a freelance PR consultant at a meeting table
Two people in an introductory meeting: communications managers review the documents of a freelance PR consultant at a meeting table · AI-generated

Which companies has the consultant placed, and where?

Ask for the track record first. Whoever is meant to get your company into the press has to show that they have done it for others. Every reference should answer three questions.

Which company? Industry, size, starting position. A mid-sized company with no press work at all is a different case from a corporation with its own press office.

Which medium, which format? An interview with the managing director in a business medium, a guest article in a trade journal, a quote in a wire report, a piece on regional radio. Each format demands a different craft.

What came of it? How many publications in what period? And what did the company get out of it: customer enquiries, applications, conversations with investors?

Everything else in this article comes after that. A consultant with a shiny CV and no documented placements remains a gamble.

Three examples from my own practice: for TikTok Shop, placements in WirtschaftsWoche and Business Insider followed within a short time. Steinbeis M&A appeared in Pioneer, FINANCE and Unternehmeredition. GO Jugendreisen had a strong marketing team but nobody for press work. Within eight weeks, five publications came together across regional media, trade media, radio and podcasts. Every consultant should be able to give you figures like these. They are no guarantee for your case, but they are proof of how someone works and what it yields. You will find the case studies on the references page.

What makes a reference reliable?

Evidence you can check. A wall of media logos shows where someone once appeared. It does not show for whom, or with what share of their own. Three checks are enough. On top of that comes one exclusion criterion.

Have the articles shown to you. Links or copies, logos alone are not enough.

Ask about their own share. Did the consultant develop the topic, approach the newsroom themselves, prepare the interview? Or did an agency team deliver and their name was on the cover sheet?

Speak to a former client. Anyone who did good work will gladly give you a contact person.

Publications on press portals do not count. Any text someone uploads appears there. They say nothing about the ability to convince a newsroom of a topic.

New to the market: what counts then?

The track record from earlier roles. Many freelance consultants went independent only recently, so their client list is short. They are credible if they have worked in a relevant role before: in a company’s press office or in a communications consultancy.

Then ask the same question as above. What did they achieve there? Which topics did they place in which media, which crisis did they handle, how did it end? A title such as “Head of Press Relations” proves responsibility. It does not prove a result.

Journalistic background: how much does it bring?

It helps, but it is not a requirement. I was a business journalist for twelve years at Dow Jones, at the FAZ publishing house and at dpa, then responsible for media relations, issues and crisis management at FTI Consulting and at Nestlé Deutschland. Today I work on the side of companies.

The practical benefit: anyone who received topic pitches for years and deleted most of them recognises faster whether a topic holds up. And they sharpen it the way a newsroom needs it. That shows in the end exactly where it counts: in the references. There are good consultants without newsroom experience. Measure both by the result.

How important are journalist contacts?

Less important than many consultants claim. Contacts are a popular sales argument, usually without proof. A contact gets attention: the email is opened, the call is taken. Whether an article results is decided by the topic.

A journalist would be ill-advised to run a story that does not fit their medium just because they know the sender. Their readers notice, and so does their section editor. Newsrooms say so themselves: 53 percent of the journalists surveyed want fact-based, transparent communication, 35 percent want targeted topic suggestions instead of mass mailings1.

If a consultant advertises with contacts, ask back: which stories came out of these contacts, and for whom? Then you are back at the references. More on this in the article “Journalist contacts are secondary”.

What comes after the references?

Working style, capacity and offer. These points decide between two consultants with a good track record. They do not make up for a weak one.

Rank Criterion What you check
1 References Which company, which medium, which format, which result, which share of their own
2 Earlier roles For new consultants: documented successes from a company or agency
3 Working style and capacity Fixed contact person, parallel clients, cover, start date
4 Offer In writing, with scope, terms and what counts as a result

What media relations cost and why the remuneration model matters more than the individual price is covered in the article “What professional media relations cost”.

Which question do you bring to the first meeting?

This one: which companies have you placed where, and what became of it? A good consultant answers it with names, media and links. They also tell you openly whether your topic holds up for newsrooms.

At BAMBERG Reputation a fixed process follows: kick-off on business goal and target group, three to five viable theses, a prioritised media list, then the personal approach to journalists up to quote approval. The details are on the page Strategic media relations. A first meeting costs nothing but time.

Frequently asked questions

What is the most important criterion when choosing a freelance PR consultant?

Their documented track record. Which companies did they get into which media, and what did it do for them?

Are big media names in references proof of quality?

Not on their own. What matters is which company the article was written for and what share the consultant had in it.

Do I need a consultant with a journalistic background?

No. It helps in finding and sharpening topics. Whether that succeeds shows in the references.

How much are journalist contacts worth?

They get attention. What gets published is what holds up editorially.

Can a freelance PR consultant guarantee publications?

No. Newsrooms decide independently. Reputable consultants tell you up front which topics have a chance.

How many references should a PR consultant be able to show?

There is no fixed number. Two or three well-documented cases from your environment say more than twenty logos.

Sources

  1. newsaktuell.denewsaktuell.de/blog/medientrendmonitor-2025-was-journalistinnen-und-journalisten-von-pr-rofis-erwarten/
  2. gpra.degpra.de/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/GPRA-Wegweiser-Agenturauswahl.pdf

Follow Florian Bamberg on LinkedIn