Ad, advertorial or editorial coverage: what works when

This article was created with the help of AI.
A middle-aged man sits by the window of a café reading a newspaper attentively, a cup of coffee beside him
A middle-aged man sits by the window of a café reading a newspaper attentively, a cup of coffee beside him · AI-generated

What distinguishes the three formats?

The three formats differ on one point: who has the last word. With an ad, you have it. With an advertorial, you share it with the publisher. With an editorial article, the editorial team has it. That determines what you have to deliver for the format to work.

Format What you buy Your control How the reader reads it
Ad Advertising space Content, date, placement As advertising
Advertorial Paid text styled like an article Largely the content, labelled as an ad As advertising in a different guise
Editorial article Nothing Your own statements and quotes As independent coverage

When is an ad the right choice?

When the date and the wording have to be fixed. For a trade fair, a product launch, prices and technical details that no editorial team would take over as they stand. The ad appears on the day you want, with exactly the text you approved.

Its limit is its effect. Readers recognise advertising and read it for what it is: your own statement about yourself. It also does little for visibility in ChatGPT, Perplexity and other AI assistants. These systems rely mainly on editorial content.

When does an advertorial work?

When a topic needs space and you have figures of your own. A market overview, a study, a customer case with solid facts: an ad is too short for that, and an editorial team rarely takes it on at this length.

An advertorial does not have to surprise anyone. Many of these pieces explain a product, show a satisfied customer and list the benefits. That is thin on substance but can still sell: anyone who is looking for a solution anyway reads exactly this kind of thing. The German Press Council requires the label “Anzeige” (advertisement)1, so readers know that you paid. For sales, that is often secondary. For credibility, the format is therefore of little use.

Before booking, ask the publisher how the labelling and layout will look. Then you know what you are getting.

What is the editorial route worth?

When credibility is the goal. Its value lies precisely in the fact that an editorial team decided to report on you, and that nobody can buy that decision.

For B2B decision-makers, the trade press is the most important source. According to the 2024 LAE special analysis, 45.2 percent of professional decision-makers use trade journals regularly, and 85.5 percent regularly or occasionally2. And editorial teams work with what companies offer them: press releases and personal conversations are journalists’ most important research sources3.

The route is open, but you have to win an editorial team over to your topic. That only works with something new. How new depends on the medium.

In the trade press, news from the industry is often enough: a new process, an order, a figure that interests colleagues and competitors. Trade editors live off this curiosity of their readers.

For the major business media the bar is higher. There you have to say something that clearly differs from what everyone else is saying, and tie it to a topic that is being discussed right now. An example from my work: an M&A advisory firm commented on succession in mid-sized businesses. The topic is well known, the statement was not: the succession wave is stalling, and until 2029 an estimated 114,000 businesses a year are set to close4. That became a guest article in The Pioneer.

In return, you give up control. The editorial team shortens, postpones or rejects. How to develop a topic that clears this hurdle is something I describe in the article The story is what counts.

How do you decide in a specific case?

Four questions are enough.

What should the measure achieve? New business, investor confidence, applicants, protecting your reputation. The goal determines the target group, and the target group determines the format.

By when does it have to work? A fixed date speaks for an ad or an advertorial. If you are building trust over the long term, you can plan for the lead time of the editorial route.

What do you have to say? A product message without news value belongs in an ad or an advertorial. News from the industry can carry an article in the trade press. If you want to reach the major media, you need a statement that stands out and a current occasion.

Which medium does your target group read? A trade journal with exactly your customers beats a national paper with ten times the circulation if nobody who buys from you reads it.

If the news value is missing, the first step is topic development. A structured stocktake is provided by the 18-question check of the 6S model.

Coverage is the foundation

Ads and advertorials have their place for fixed dates, in sales and for topics that need explaining. The foundation of media relations that pays off for the business remains coverage in the media your target group reads. How I go about it, from the kick-off through topic development to support during the interview, is described under “strategic media relations & placements in trade and business media”. The way in is a free 30-minute initial consultation.

And if the question is whether an ad wouldn’t be simpler: simpler, yes. Effective for credibility, no.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between an ad and an editorial article?

You pay for and design the ad yourself, and you decide on content and date. The editorial team decides on the editorial article, and it can shorten, postpone or reject it. That is why readers trust editorial coverage more.

Does an advertorial have to be labelled?

Yes. The German Press Code requires that paid publications are recognisable to the reader as advertising. The German Press Council does not consider terms such as “advertorial” or “sponsored post” sufficient and expects the label “Anzeige” (advertisement).

What is covert advertising?

Covert advertising is paid advertising disguised as editorial content. It violates the Press Code and can have consequences under competition law. The Press Council regularly reprimands such cases, and in the end the credibility of the publication suffers as much as that of the company.

When is an ad better than media relations?

When the date and the wording have to be fixed, for example for a trade fair, a product launch or price information. An ad is also the right way if you want to sell and have no news that interests an editorial team. For credibility, media relations are stronger.

Can an advertorial work like an editorial article?

For sales, often yes, because it explains things at length and reaches readers who are already looking for a solution. For credibility, hardly, because it is labelled as an ad.

Does an ad help with visibility in ChatGPT and other AI assistants?

Very little. AI assistants such as ChatGPT and Perplexity rely mainly on editorial coverage. If you want to appear in their answers, you need articles in media that these systems use as a source.

Which media do B2B decision-makers use?

Mainly trade journals. According to the 2024 LAE special analysis, 45.2 percent of professional decision-makers read them regularly, and 85.5 percent regularly or occasionally.

How does a company get into editorial coverage?

With something new. In the trade press, news from the industry is often enough. For major business media you need a statement that stands apart from others and ties in with a current topic.

Sources

  1. presserat.depresserat.de/presserat-schleichwerbung.html
  2. deutsche-fachpresse.dedeutsche-fachpresse.de/markt-studien/fachmediennutzung-entscheider-lae/
  3. newsaktuell.denewsaktuell.de/blog/medien-trendmonitor-2025-wie-journalistinnen-und-journalisten-mit-pr-material-arbeiten/
  4. ihk.deihk.de/hannover/hauptnavigation/gruendung-sicherung-nachfolge/aktuell/neuer-inhalt5-6934976

Follow Florian Bamberg on LinkedIn