Litigation PR: communicating while the lawsuit is running

This article was created with the help of AI.
Two managing directors and an adviser prepare for press questions in front of a regional court building, with journalists holding notepads and cameras in the background.
Two managing directors and an adviser prepare for press questions in front of a regional court building, with journalists holding notepads and cameras in the background. · AI-generated

What does litigation PR have to achieve?

Litigation PR has three tasks. It must not burden the proceedings. It protects the company’s reputation while the proceedings are running. It improves the environment of the trial. The aim is clear: you give the other side no additional ammunition and make your own position publicly visible.

Litigation PR has no influence on the judgment. The judges say so themselves. A study by the MHMK Macromedia University of Applied Sciences for Media and Communication from 2010 makes this clear. Around 50 percent of the lawyers surveyed believe litigation PR can influence the outcome of a trial. Judges and prosecutors consider it unimportant1. That takes pressure off the communication.

Brigitte Koppenhöfer, former presiding judge at the Regional Court of Düsseldorf, draws the line: “The trial is decided in the courtroom, not in the press.” Peter Clemen, president of the Regional Court of Detmold, puts it similarly: “The primary point of contact for litigation PR […] is the media.”2 Communication does affect the environment of the proceedings. It influences the other side’s willingness to settle and the picture among politicians, regulators, customers and business partners. The real risk is the careless sentence that ultimately harms the case.

Who leads the communication?

Communications leads. The law firm reviews every statement, holds a veto and does not write the sentences. Anyone who hands the pen to the lawyers gets statements that hold up in court and lose in the newspaper.

Exactly one person in the company gives final approval, with a named deputy. This person is responsible for the effect on the outside world.

Employees who speak freely about facts quickly become interesting witnesses for the other side3. That is why you name fixed contacts for the media. Everyone else refers questions to this point.

Why is silence not an option?

Newsrooms ask for statements, whether the company wants this or declines. Anyone who says nothing leaves the public interpretation entirely to the other side. The sentence “We do not comment on ongoing proceedings” is almost always the weakest sentence. How dangerous this silence becomes when an NGO attacks at the same time is shown by the case in the next section.

What should you do if an NGO sues and attacks publicly at the same time?

There is an asymmetry here. The NGO may sharpen its message, the company has to stay legally clean. The answer is: anticipate the dramaturgy of the campaign. You must have reactions ready before the next step of the campaign comes. A public attack on the NGO itself is out of the question, as it makes the NGO the David and the company the Goliath.

A case from my earlier in-house role, before I founded BAMBERG Reputation, illustrates this. An international food group came under pressure over one product division. Investigations by two media outlets abroad raised the question of whether the processing methods used were compatible with the labelling of the products. The allegation concerned the foundation of the business. An NGO filed a criminal complaint, a parliamentary inquiry began. Coverage did not let up for months.

In Germany, newsrooms wanted to know what the case meant for the products sold here. I supported the media relations for the German market for over a year. We played through the other side’s possible next steps, from further advertisements to test purchases and new publications. The reactions were ready and waiting. We evaluated the coverage daily. That way we saw early which account was becoming entrenched and where a newsroom was working with an incomplete picture. The case played out abroad and concerned different products from those on the shelves in Germany. This distinction was lost several times in the coverage. I contacted the newsrooms, supplied the missing facts and placed the company’s position, including at the highest-circulation newspaper in Germany. As a result, the German coverage became more precise and classified the facts correctly. The company’s position was represented in the key titles.

Which statements hold up while the proceedings are running?

A statement holds up if it is pointed and legally clean. Do not be afraid of clear sentences. Every sentence must be able to stand on its own when a newsroom cuts it out. On the day of the hearing, statements are made in front of the courtroom; cameras are forbidden inside. Subjunctives, hedging, predictions about the judgment and admissions of guilt between the lines have to go.

You need a core message on one page plus a catalogue of questions with the hard questions. A weak example is: “We do not comment on ongoing proceedings.” A strong example is: “The products sold in Germany are not affected by the allegations.” For exactly how to structure critical enquiries, read the article Critical press enquiry: how to prepare your response.

How do you reach the public between hearings?

Press enquiries come in waves. In between lie months. Your own channels carry the communication over this long period. A legally reviewed FAQ on the website serves as a public fact base to which every statement refers. Employees also use this information. From a location dispute with local politics I know this FAQ as the most effective tool. How to place statements is covered under Publishing a statement: where, when and when better not.

Put a search ad budget behind this FAQ. Anyone who searches for the company name and the word lawsuit, or the product and the word allegations, lands on the company’s account of events. The ad is labelled, which is perfectly fine. What matters is the content behind it. A well-built FAQ is also a source for ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews when someone asks about the case there.

Planning proceedings communication in the initial consultation

The yardstick for every single measure stays the same: does it reduce the expected damage, or does it create attention that would not exist otherwise? This trade-off belongs on the table again with every new development, for example when a hearing date is set or the other side reacts publicly. How to recognise a suitable adviser is described in the article Choosing a crisis communicator: who can help in an acute crisis?.

Proceedings communication can be planned. The right time is the filing of the lawsuit, certainly not only the first call from a newsroom. At BAMBERG Reputation this falls under issues and crisis communications: I personally accompany companies through proceedings, NGO campaigns and long conflicts, reachable around the clock, with a reply within 15 minutes.

Preparation and activation can be commissioned separately, and activation takes place only on your express instruction. The fee depends on the size of the crisis, the expected damage, scope and duration; smaller assignments can stay well below a five-figure amount, extensive mandates with both phases are in the five-figure range, billed at a fixed fee per phase. If a lawsuit is running in your company or is looming, plan the proceedings communication in the initial consultation: on the page for issues and crisis communications you can see how the support works in practice.

Frequently asked questions

What does litigation PR mean?

Litigation PR is strategic legal communication: media relations around a legal dispute, which emerged in the USA in the 1980s. It protects the company's reputation while the proceedings are running and makes sure your own position appears in the coverage.

Can litigation PR influence the outcome of a court case?

It has no influence on the judgment, as judges and prosecutors themselves say[1]. It does affect the environment of the proceedings: the other side's willingness to settle, politics, regulators, customers and business partners. The biggest risk is a careless sentence that harms the case.

Who decides what is said publicly during the lawsuit?

Communications drafts, the law firm reviews and holds a veto, and one named person in the company gives final approval. These roles are fixed before the first statement, as is the deputy for the person who approves.

Can lawyers forbid statements?

Yes, the law firm has a veto if a statement carries legal risk. Communications still writes the sentences. Anyone who hands the pen to the lawyers gets statements that hold up in court and lose in the newspaper.

Should a company communicate at all during a lawsuit?

Yes, as soon as newsrooms ask. Staying silent then leaves the interpretation to the other side. Without an enquiry a different yardstick applies: does the statement reduce the expected damage, or does it create attention that would not exist otherwise? In the second case, restraint is the better choice.

How do you react when an NGO sues and runs a campaign at the same time?

With preparation. An NGO campaign follows a dramaturgy of advertisements, test purchases and new publications. Anyone who plays through these steps has the reaction ready before the next step comes. A public attack on the NGO itself almost always harms the company.

Are search ads worthwhile in a crisis?

Yes, if a legally reviewed FAQ stands behind them. Anyone who googles the company name and the lawsuit then lands on the company's account of events. The ad is labelled; the content is what matters. A well-built FAQ also serves ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews as a source.

What does external support for proceedings communication cost?

That depends on the size of the crisis, the expected damage, scope and duration. Smaller assignments often stay well below a five-figure amount, extensive mandates with preparation and activation are in the five-figure range. Both phases are billed separately at a fixed fee, activation only on call.

Sources

  1. idw-online.deidw-online.de/de/news384996
  2. lto.delto.de/recht/hintergruende/h/litigation-pr-juristische-hilfsdisziplin-oder-neue-wunderwaffe
  3. anwaltsblatt.anwaltverein.deanwaltsblatt.anwaltverein.de/de/themen/kanzlei-praxis/litigation-pr-handreichung
  4. beck-aktuell.debeck-aktuell.de/daily/meldung/detail/ziviljustiz-statistisches-bundesamt-weniger-verfahren-amtsgerichte-landgerichte
  5. gesetze-im-internet.degesetze-im-internet.de/gvg/__169.html

Follow Florian Bamberg on LinkedIn